I am thinking about setting permanent "reflector" backsights at a site that I will return to many times. In particular, I am looking at Rothbucher reflective tapes that I saw in a Professional Surveyor magazine story recently.
I am concerned about having different prism constants on the project, and just how much tolerance these targets have from being shot straight on. Does anybody have experience with these?
Reflector tape backsights
-
Paul Goebel
- Posts: 105
- Joined: Wed Mar 14, 2007 1:47 pm
Reflector tape backsights
Paul E. Goebel, PLS
-
Stan_K
- Posts: 79
- Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2004 1:11 pm
- Location: Sacramento
Reflector tape backsights
Paul,
I've used many different brands of reflector tape with good results. The biggest difference was the usable distance - a direct result of the quality of the reflective material. All have a prism constant of 0 (zero).
Shooting the target at an angle MIGHT induce a distance error - this is caused by the actual size of the edm laser beam.
You will need an X,Y,Z coordinate on the reflector tape, therefore you need to use the correct prism contant. Yes, I know some data collectors are easier to switch than others - Sorry.
Use good adhesive! Reflector tape has saved our rear-ends many times on construction sites. Set them off-site or where generally not visible to the construction crews. If they can't see them, they can't move them!
I've used many different brands of reflector tape with good results. The biggest difference was the usable distance - a direct result of the quality of the reflective material. All have a prism constant of 0 (zero).
Shooting the target at an angle MIGHT induce a distance error - this is caused by the actual size of the edm laser beam.
You will need an X,Y,Z coordinate on the reflector tape, therefore you need to use the correct prism contant. Yes, I know some data collectors are easier to switch than others - Sorry.
Use good adhesive! Reflector tape has saved our rear-ends many times on construction sites. Set them off-site or where generally not visible to the construction crews. If they can't see them, they can't move them!
Stanley King, CA PLS 8038
- Ian Wilson
- Posts: 1087
- Joined: Sat Aug 03, 2002 6:58 am
- Location: Bay Area
Bicycle reflectors expoxied on to bridge abutments, etc. make great “permanent backsights”, too
You can even get fancy and use the white ones and paint a pair of opposing quadrant on the face of the reflector with transparent candy apple red model paint to give yourself a nice aiming target.
Stick with one style and brand of reflectors and check to prism offset constant against a prism of know offset before you stick one up somewhere. The offset will be a function of the thickness of the reflector layer.
You can even get fancy and use the white ones and paint a pair of opposing quadrant on the face of the reflector with transparent candy apple red model paint to give yourself a nice aiming target.
Stick with one style and brand of reflectors and check to prism offset constant against a prism of know offset before you stick one up somewhere. The offset will be a function of the thickness of the reflector layer.
Ian Wilson, P.L.S. (CA / NV / CO)
Alameda County Surveyor
Alameda County Surveyor
-
Paul Goebel
- Posts: 105
- Joined: Wed Mar 14, 2007 1:47 pm
I hadn’t thought about the bicycle reflectors in a while. My data collector is one that won’t accept more that one prism constant at one time, so changing that would be a minor inconvenience. One of the backsight positions on my project would need to be shot from many different angles, so a 360° prism would be ideal if I could afford it.
Paul E. Goebel, PLS
-
Scott
- Posts: 258
- Joined: Mon Oct 11, 2004 11:52 am
- Location: Modesto, CA
Reflectors
If you glue the reflector and then locate it from a few different control points and put those locations in any adjustment you do to the site, prism constant should not be a factor because you are just flat out locating the refelctor itself and any inherent prism factor wherever it is shooting to. You don't need to know exactly where the wall is (which is what the prism constant would give you) that the reflector is attached to. Does that make any sense?
Scott DeLaMare
LS 8078
LS 8078
-
Paul Goebel
- Posts: 105
- Joined: Wed Mar 14, 2007 1:47 pm
-
Scott
- Posts: 258
- Joined: Mon Oct 11, 2004 11:52 am
- Location: Modesto, CA
Black line
Then all you need is a line drawn on the wall and no reflector. Go reflectorless and still use the black line.
Scott DeLaMare
LS 8078
LS 8078
-
D Ryan
- Posts: 188
- Joined: Fri Aug 23, 2002 12:20 pm
- Location: Arcata, CA
The reflectors add the option of doing a "re-section" if you lose control. Will work for both vertical and horizontal. We have a few gravel bars where we lose our convenient control every year. One of those sites has a railroad bridge that goes right by the site we have some RP's on that we use for pulling the control back in. l've always thought that site would be ideal for a few pieces of reflector tape for "re-sections".
Our reflectorless gun automatically goes to zero prism offset when in refelectorless mode, so that takes the data collector out of the equation. Of course you have remember to punch the hot key on the total station to set it back to 30 or your next series of shots are screwed (well, by .09' if it matters...).
Dave Ryan
Humboldt County
Our reflectorless gun automatically goes to zero prism offset when in refelectorless mode, so that takes the data collector out of the equation. Of course you have remember to punch the hot key on the total station to set it back to 30 or your next series of shots are screwed (well, by .09' if it matters...).
Dave Ryan
Humboldt County
-
Paul Goebel
- Posts: 105
- Joined: Wed Mar 14, 2007 1:47 pm
-
goodgps
- Posts: 642
- Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2008 7:32 pm
- Location: Modesto, Ca
We put reflector tape on rain boots to do topo in wooded areas where the inst man (person) can only see below the leafy area. it works pretty well.
"boot men" clobber around in the forest Less chopping and destroying of vegitation. "p"architects really love this method, because it saves their wooded areas.
signed
"Woody Slopes"
"boot men" clobber around in the forest Less chopping and destroying of vegitation. "p"architects really love this method, because it saves their wooded areas.
signed
"Woody Slopes"